Array Stack vs Linked List Stack in .NET: Which Should You Use?
💡 Concept Name
Stack Implementation: Array vs Linked List
📘 Quick Intro
A stack can be built with either an array or a linked list. Both follow Last-In-First-Out (LIFO), but their internal structure, scalability, and performance can feel very different—especially as your app grows. Let’s see what really happens under the hood.
🧠 Analogy / Short Story
Think of stacking plates at a buffet. If you use an array, it’s like a fixed-size shelf—once the shelf is full, you can't add more unless you replace the shelf with a bigger one. With a linked list, it’s like stacking plates freely on a table: you can keep going as long as you have plates and space, but each plate needs a little name tag (pointer), so it’s a bit more effort per plate.
🔧 Technical Explanation
- 📦 Array Stack: Stores elements in a continuous memory block. Super-fast and cache-friendly, but must set a size ahead of time or handle resizing manually.
- 🔗 Linked List Stack: Each item is a node pointing to the next. Grows naturally, never runs out of space unless memory does, but uses extra memory for links (pointers).
- ⏱️ Both allow O(1) push and pop, but array-based stacks may occasionally pause to resize (usually by doubling size).
- 🔄 Linked lists shine when you need unlimited growth or lots of insertions/removals, but can be slower due to non-contiguous memory.
- 📊 In .NET, the built-in
Stack<T>uses arrays under the hood for best average-case speed.
Personal tip: If you know your maximum stack size (like parsing a small expression), arrays are great. For unpredictable size or frequent changes, linked lists feel smoother.
🎯 Purpose & Use Case
- ✅ Choose arrays when you want speed and can estimate or cap the maximum stack size up front.
- ✅ Go with linked lists for stacks that grow or shrink without predictable limits—like in interpreters or when simulating recursion.
- ✅ Both are used in undo-redo logic, backtracking algorithms, and expression evaluation—just pick the right tool for your scenario.
💻 Real Code Example
// Array-based stack implementation
public class ArrayStack
{
private T[] items;
private int top = -1;
public ArrayStack(int size) { items = new T[size]; }
public void Push(T item)
{
if (top == items.Length - 1) throw new Exception("Stack Overflow");
items[++top] = item;
}
public T Pop()
{
if (top == -1) throw new Exception("Stack Underflow");
return items[top--];
}
}
// Linked list-based stack implementation
public class LinkedStack
{
private class Node { public T Data; public Node Next; }
private Node top;
public void Push(T item) { top = new Node { Data = item, Next = top }; }
public T Pop()
{
if (top == null) throw new Exception("Stack Underflow");
T value = top.Data;
top = top.Next;
return value;
}
}
❓ Interview Q&A
Q1: What is a stack in data structures?
A: It’s a LIFO (Last-In-First-Out) structure—think undo history or browser back button.
Q2: Why use an array for a stack?
A: For speed, tight memory use, and fast cache performance when max size is known.
Q3: When does a linked list stack make sense?
A: When stack size is unpredictable or grows/shrinks often.
Q4: Which is more memory efficient?
A: Arrays—no per-element pointer overhead.
Q5: What does “stack overflow” mean for array stacks?
A: Trying to add more items than the array’s capacity allows.
Q6: Are stack operations O(1) in both implementations?
A: Yes—for push and pop, unless array resizes are triggered.
Q7: Is stack traversal common?
A: It’s possible, but in real applications, stacks are rarely traversed—just pushed or popped.
Q8: Does .NET’s Stack<T> use arrays or linked lists?
A: Internally, it’s array-based for performance.
Q9: What’s the trade-off for linked list stacks?
A: Extra memory per node for pointers, and potential CPU cache misses.
Q10: How do you decide which to use?
A: Estimate your max size and performance needs—arrays for speed and predictability, linked lists for flexibility.
📝 MCQs
Q1. Which stack type grows naturally with new items?
- Array stack
- Linked list stack
- HashSet
- ArrayList
Q2. Which is best for tight memory use?
- Array stack
- Linked list stack
- Queue
- Deque
Q3. What is the typical time for push/pop?
- O(1) in both
- O(n)
- O(log n)
- O(1) in array only
Q4. What triggers resizing in array stacks?
- Low memory
- Exceeding capacity
- Duplicate items
- Type mismatch
Q5. Which stack has pointer overhead?
- Array stack
- Linked list stack
- Both
- Neither
Q6. Why are array stacks usually faster?
- More memory
- Better CPU cache locality
- Linked nodes
- Larger size
Q7. Which is better for unknown stack size?
- Array stack
- Linked list stack
- Queue
- ArrayList
Q8. What happens if you push to a full array stack?
- Stack overflow
- Stack underflow
- Silent ignore
- Automatic resize always
Q9. Is .NET's built-in Stack<T> array-based?
- Yes
- No
- Optional
- Depends on version
Q10. Which is preferred for undo/redo logic?
- Array stack
- Linked list stack
- Either, depending on app
- List<T>
💡 Bonus Insight
Most production code in .NET uses Stack<T>—fast, reliable, and battle-tested. But knowing the difference between array and linked list stacks can help you optimize for edge cases, pass interviews, and even debug memory issues nobody else can spot!
📄 PDF Download
Need a handy summary for your notes? Download this topic as a PDF!
Grab this comparison as a handy PDF for your next interview or code review!