SQL Functions vs Procedures: Key Differences
💡 Concept Name
SQL Functions vs Stored Procedures – Two types of database objects used to encapsulate reusable logic, but with key differences in behavior, syntax, and use cases.
📘 Quick Intro
Functions and procedures in SQL both allow reusable logic, but serve different purposes. Functions always return a value and can be used in SELECT statements, while procedures are more flexible, can return zero or many values, and support full control flow with side effects like modifying tables. Functions are ideal for calculations and transformations, whereas procedures are suited for transactions and complex workflows. Understanding the differences helps in writing more maintainable and secure database code.
🧠 Analogy / Short Story
Think of a function like a calculator—you give it input, and it returns a precise result. A procedure is more like a full recipe; it can read, write, cook, and clean up. While the calculator can be embedded anywhere (like inside a sentence), a recipe must be executed on its own. In SQL, functions are tools used in expressions, while procedures are standalone operations for multi-step logic.
🔧 Technical Explanation
- 🧮 Functions must return a value and can be used in SELECT, WHERE, or JOIN clauses.
- 🔁 Procedures can return zero, one, or multiple values and can include control-of-flow statements.
- ❌ Functions cannot modify table data directly (no INSERT/UPDATE/DELETE), while procedures can.
- 🧼 Procedures support output parameters and transactions; functions do not.
- 🔎 Functions are more restricted for purity and determinism; procedures are more flexible.
🎯 Purpose & Use Case
- ✅ Use functions for reusable calculations (e.g., full name formatter, tax calculations).
- ✅ Use procedures for workflows involving multiple steps or data modifications.
- ✅ Prefer functions when you need inline logic inside queries.
- ✅ Use procedures when you want to encapsulate logic behind stored logic that runs with EXEC.
💻 Real Code Example
-- SQL Server Function
CREATE FUNCTION dbo.GetFullName (@FirstName NVARCHAR(50), @LastName NVARCHAR(50))
RETURNS NVARCHAR(101)
AS
BEGIN
RETURN @FirstName + ' ' + @LastName;
END;
-- SQL Server Procedure
CREATE PROCEDURE dbo.InsertUser
@FirstName NVARCHAR(50),
@LastName NVARCHAR(50)
AS
BEGIN
INSERT INTO Users (FirstName, LastName) VALUES (@FirstName, @LastName);
END;
-- Usage
SELECT dbo.GetFullName('John', 'Doe'); -- Used in query
EXEC dbo.InsertUser 'Jane', 'Doe'; -- Executed independently
❓ Interview Q&A
Q1: What is the main difference between a function and a procedure in SQL?
A: A function returns a single value and can be used in expressions, whereas a procedure performs actions and is executed independently.
Q2: Can a SQL function modify database tables?
A: No, functions cannot change database state (no INSERT, UPDATE, or DELETE).
Q3: Can stored procedures return values?
A: Yes, they can return output parameters or result sets but not like scalar function return types.
Q4: When should I use a function in SQL?
A: When you need reusable, inline logic like calculations or transformations inside queries.
Q5: Which supports transactions: function or procedure?
A: Procedures support transactions; functions do not.
Q6: Can you call a procedure in a SELECT query?
A: No, procedures must be executed using EXEC, not embedded in SELECT.
Q7: What’s a common use case for procedures?
A: Inserting records, processing batch updates, or performing multiple-step operations.
Q8: Are functions deterministic in SQL?
A: Yes, they should return the same result for the same input.
Q9: Can both functions and procedures have input parameters?
A: Yes, both support input parameters.
Q10: Which is more flexible for multi-step logic?
A: Stored procedures, because they allow control-of-flow, DML, and output variables.
📝 MCQs
Q1. What is the key difference between SQL functions and procedures?
- Functions sort tables
- Functions return values; procedures execute logic
- Procedures are faster
- Functions modify tables
Q2. Which can be used in a SELECT statement?
- Procedure
- Trigger
- Function
- Cursor
Q3. Which SQL object supports transactions?
- Function
- Stored Procedure
- View
- Index
Q4. Can a function modify table data?
- Yes
- No
- Sometimes
- Only in MySQL
Q5. Which supports output parameters?
- Procedure
- Function
- Index
- View
Q6. How do you execute a procedure in SQL Server?
- SELECT ProcedureName()
- EXEC ProcedureName
- RUN ProcedureName
- CALL ProcedureName()
Q7. Which is better for batch updates?
- Trigger
- Procedure
- Function
- Table
Q8. What keyword is required in a function?
- RETURNS
- OUTPUT
- INTO
- RUN
Q9. Which allows more flexible logic and control flow?
- Function
- Procedure
- View
- Join
Q10. Can a function return a table?
- No
- Yes, if it is a table-valued function
- Only in triggers
- Only with cursors
💡 Bonus Insight
In performance-critical systems, functions are preferred when embedding logic directly in queries, while procedures are great for modularizing complex processes. Some DBMS allow table-valued functions, offering a hybrid approach. Always follow your DBMS’s limitations and best practices when choosing between the two.
📄 PDF Download
Need a handy summary for your notes? Download this topic as a PDF!